Ready-mix or bags? The break-even slab size
At $6.47 for an 80 lb bag, bags stayed cheaper than a ready-mix truck up to about 1.6 cubic yards at one California plant and about 3 cubic yards at one metro Atlanta supplier. Past 1.7 and 3.7 yards, the truck won every time. Those yards are the slab itself, before the 10% extra. For a 4 inch slab, that’s roughly 140 square feet in Vacaville and 300 in Atlanta, so a 10 x 12 patio still comes out cheaper in bags in both places.
The reason is fixed fees. A truck carries a delivery charge and a short-load fee before the first yard is poured, so a single yard costs $382 at one and $490 at the other. That’s the price of 59 and 75 bags.
We priced it from two plants that post their full price lists online, plus Home Depot’s bag price, all read on November 9, 2026. Your prices will differ. The method won’t, and the table further down shows how the line moves when your bags cost more or less.
What a small truck load costs
| Townsend Concrete, Vacaville, CA | Quick Mix Concrete, metro Atlanta, GA | |
|---|---|---|
| 3,000 psi mix, per cubic yard | $162 (5 sack) | $195 |
| Per delivery | $120 delivery fee | $95 fuel and environmental charge |
| Short-load fee | $100, below 3 yards | $200, under 6 yards |
| Smallest bill | 1 yard minimum charge ($162) | not stated |
| Sold in | not stated | half yards |
| Bill for 1 yard, before tax | $382 | $490, if it delivers 1 yard |
Sources: Townsend Concrete’s price list (Vacaville, Dixon and Winters zone; farther zones pay up to $350 delivery with a 6 yard short-load line) and Quick Mix Concrete’s pricing page. Neither page shows a date for its prices, and both say they’re subject to change. Townsend’s prices are “plus tax.”
Townsend shrinks its short-load fee near the line: it’s “$100 or discounted to the cost of the difference” between the threshold and the concrete delivered, whichever is less. We read that as the missing yards at $162. It’s a fair rule. It only matters between about 2.4 and 3 yards, and it means ordering 2.5 yards there costs the same $606 as ordering 3.
Quick Mix doesn’t list a minimum order, so we started it at 1 yard. A minimum of up to 2 yards wouldn’t move any crossing in this guide. It would only raise the Atlanta price for the two smallest slabs, which are bag jobs either way. Townsend doesn’t say what steps it sells in, so we rounded its orders up to the quarter yard, the way our concrete calculator rounds ready-mix.
The bag side
Home Depot’s online listings showed Quikrete’s 80 lb Concrete Mix at $6.47 on November 9, 2026. Quikrete’s data sheet for Concrete Mix No. 1101 puts the yield at about 0.60 cubic feet a bag, so a cubic yard takes 45 bags (our post on how many bags of concrete make a yard checks that number against other calculators). That’s $291.15 a yard. The trucks charge $162 and $195.
So bags lose on every yard. They only win because the truck’s $220 to $295 in fees comes first.
The 60 lb bag was $4.85, and at 0.45 cubic feet that works out to $10.78 a cubic foot, exactly what the 80 lb bag costs. And a pallet of 42 bags of 80 lb was $271.74, which is $6.47 a bag again. Buying by the pallet saved nothing at that listing.
Six slabs priced both ways
All 4 inches thick, with 10% extra on both sides (our calculator’s default, and what Duke City Redi-Mix tells customers to add). Bags are rounded up to whole bags. Costs are before tax.
| Slab | Concrete | 80 lb bags | Bags at $6.47 | Vacaville truck | Atlanta truck |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 x 8 | 0.79 yd | 40 | $258.80 | $382 (1 yd) | $490 (1 yd) |
| 10 x 10 | 1.23 yd | 62 | $401.14 | $463 (1.5 yd) | $587.50 (1.5 yd) |
| 10 x 12 | 1.48 yd | 74 | $478.78 | $503.50 (1.75 yd) | $685 (2 yd) |
| 12 x 12 | 1.78 yd | 88 | $569.36 | $544 (2 yd) | $685 (2 yd) |
| 10 x 20 | 2.47 yd | 123 | $795.81 | $606 (2.75 yd) | $880 (3 yd) |
| 20 x 20 | 4.94 yd | 245 | $1,585.15 | $1,011 (5.5 yd) | $1,265 (6 yd) |
Bold marks the cases where the truck is cheaper. The 10 x 12 is the close one in Vacaville: $25 apart, and that’s before anyone counts a mixer or a sore back. 74 bags is 5,920 lb of dry mix.
The Atlanta 20 x 20 needs 5.5 yards with the extra, which would cost $1,367.50 with the short-load fee. Order 6 yards and the fee disappears: $1,265, so you pay less for more concrete. Order 5 and it’s $1,270. At this plant, if you need 5 or 5.5 yards, buy 6. Duke City makes the same point about its own 5 yard line.
The truck lines are stairs because orders go up in quarter or half yards. Near the crossing, that means the cheaper option can flip back and forth for a few square feet. In Vacaville it flips between 127 and 137 square feet; in Atlanta, between 248 and 296.
If your bags cost more or less
Bag prices change by store and by season, so here’s the same crossing at four bag prices. “Bags win up to” means bags cost less at every size up to that one. “Truck wins from” is where the truck stays cheaper from then on. In between, it flips.
| 80 lb bag price | Vacaville: bags win up to | Vacaville: truck wins from | Atlanta: bags win up to | Atlanta: truck wins from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5.50 | 180 sq ft (2.2 yd) | 181 sq ft | 405 sq ft (5.0 yd) | 406 sq ft |
| $6.47 | 126 sq ft (1.6 yd) | 138 sq ft (1.7 yd) | 247 sq ft (3.0 yd) | 297 sq ft (3.7 yd) |
| $7.50 | 91 sq ft (1.1 yd) | 100 sq ft (1.2 yd) | 170 sq ft (2.1 yd) | 192 sq ft (2.4 yd) |
| $8.50 | 72 sq ft (0.9 yd) | 81 sq ft (1.0 yd) | 130 sq ft (1.6 yd) | 151 sq ft (1.9 yd) |
Square feet are for 4 inches thick. For a 6 inch slab, take two thirds of the area; the cubic yards stay the same.
The plant matters more than the bag. A dollar a bag moves the Vacaville line by about 40 square feet, while switching from the Vacaville plant to the Atlanta one, with the same $6.47 bag, moved it by about 160. Call the plant first.
Two rules of thumb we checked
HomeGuide’s concrete delivery cost page says bags “can be cheaper” for projects under 1 cubic yard and that past that, ready-mix “is almost always more cost-effective.” At both plants we priced, bags were still cheaper at 1.2 yards (the 10 x 10), and in Atlanta at about 2.5 (the 10 x 20). One yard is too low a line when the plant charges a short-load fee.
SlashGear’s May 2026 piece cites estimates of $300 to $350 for 2 cubic yards of ready-mix and adds that delivery fees may raise that. They do. With every fee in, 2 yards came to $544 in Vacaville and $685 in Atlanta.
Both pages have the direction right. They just put the line too low.
Things that move the line
Weekends cost more. Townsend adds $100 on Saturday and $200 on Sunday, so a Saturday pour moves the Vacaville crossing from 138 square feet out to 179 (2.2 yards).
The clock runs while the truck unloads. Townsend allows 5 minutes a yard, or 20 minutes for loads of 4 yards or less, then charges $10 for every 5 minutes. If the truck can’t reach your forms and everything goes by wheelbarrow, ask how long a small load really gets.
Running short hurts more with a truck. Duke City bills a second truck as a new order, short-load fee and all. Quick Mix adds 10% a yard for concrete batched on site after the original order. Short on bags, you drive back to the store. That’s a good reason to keep the 10% extra on the truck side.
Distance counts too. In Townsend’s two farthest zones, delivery is $300 or $350, the minimum charge is 5 yards ($810) and the short-load line is 6 yards. The smallest bill there is $1,210 or $1,260, which buys 187 or 194 bags, about 4 yards of concrete.
Our take: if the slab lands inside the flip-flop band, or within about $25 of the truck price, order the truck. That takes in the 10 x 12 in Vacaville. In Atlanta it’s still a clear bag job. The bag column in our table counts only the bags. It doesn’t count a mixer, the hours, or the 6,240 to 6,720 lb of dry mix that the Vacaville band works out to (78 to 84 bags).
Run your own prices
The concrete calculator does this comparison once you have a quote. Get that first. Then enter the slab, open the price box and type in your bag price, your plant’s price per yard and its delivery and short-load fees added together. It shows both costs on one line, with the truck order rounded up to the quarter yard. If you’re also pricing the gravel base, rebar and forms, the concrete slab planner puts it all on one shopping list. For the 10 x 12 from the table, the 10 x 12 slab page has the bag counts at 4, 5 and 6 inches.